BBC revives Les Mis, but leaves the music out – Published in The South China Morning Post

Lavish adaptation of Victor Hugo’s 19th century novel is all the better for having no soundtrack, according to scriptwriter Andrew Davies

[Click on image below to view full-size page]

If you were adapting a story that has already been turned into a colossus of a stage musical and a triple-Oscar-winning Hollywood film, you might be expected to be slightly overawed by the task. The actors and producers of the latest iteration of Les Misérables – a six-part BBC take on Victor Hugo’s 1862 novel – are suitably diplomatic about the stage show seen by 70 million people in 51 countries, giving verdicts that range from “perfectly good” to “brilliant”.

But not Andrew Davies. The screenwriter behind the original House of Cards, the Pride and Prejudice adaptation that saw a wet-shirted Colin Firth emerging from a lake and an equally sexed-up War and Peace went to see the musical in London’s West End while preparing his own scripts.

“And I thought it was appalling. I hated it,” the 82-year-old proclaims, large glass of red wine in hand, ahead of the show’s global launch at the British Academy of Film and Television Arts in London.

“I did see it rather late on, probably with a second- or thirdrate cast. But, even so, I thought the lyrics were contemptible doggerel. There were one or two good tunes, but nothing that you couldn’t do without. Basically a lot of it was like a school concert with people standing in a row and singing. So part of my motivation then became to rescue Les Misérables from the musical.”

The latest dramatisation is without songs, but boasts an allstar cast, including Dominic West as Jean Valjean, David Oyelowo as Javert, Lily Collins as Fantine and Adeel Akhtar and Olivia Colman as Monsieur and Madame Thenardier. Oyelowo, now more regularly seen on the big screen, including as Martin Luther King in Selma, says he was drawn back to TV by Davies’ script, which was “literally one of the best things I ever read”.

“I don’t care who you are, I don’t think there’s been an adaptation as good as this,” he says. “There are certain stories – Shakespeare, Dickens, Austen and I would include Les Misérables the novel – that so speak to humanity. Revolution, religion, class, war, sex, love, hatred, malevolence – these are all things that mean every generation wants to tell that story [anew].”

Collins concurs. “You can smell, taste, see and hear the world,” she says, adding that even the snow and driving rain were real – as well as her bruises.

“That was my fault,” says a sheepish Oyelowo. In a scene in which a raging Javert pushes Fantine away from him, Oyelowo deployed slightly too much force, and “she literally went flying” across the cobbled stones of Limburg, Belgium. “She weighs about as much as a teaspoon,” he says in his defence. “I felt awful – she had this ginormous bruise on her hip, but she’s such a brilliant actress, she just kept going.”

After publication, Victor Hugo wrote that his story was intended to be read “in every place where man is ignorant and despairing, in every place where woman is sold for bread, wherever the child suffers  for lack of the book which should instruct him and of the hearth which should warm him”.

And Davies insists the 1,500-page book – adapted for radio and film more times than any other novel – is ripe for a revisit.

“Walking along to get to Bafta,” he says, “you’re passing people who are begging in the street, sitting in the rain, and we’re in our Chanel and our Gucci, you know, wondering how to solve all these kind of problems. Society is very much divided up into haves and have-nots now, and it was then. The Nazis seem to be coming back all over Europe. Whether revolution is a good way to solve all that … I’m not sure.”

We speak as the “gilet jaunes” riots take hold across France. Oyelowo says: “We are at a time of incredible political unrest in the world. The fact that in the trailer, it said Paris is a tinder box – I mean, you want to talk about a piece that is potent for the time, let alone the discrepancies between different classes of people and police brutality. It just shows, we don’t really learn our lesson.”

The lavish series is also given a freshness by its colour-blind casting, allowing for Adeel Akhtar and Erin Kellyman to receive their first roles in a costume drama. Kellyman, who plays Eponine and is mixed-race, tells me: “I just assumed I would never do period drama. It just never seemed like it was an option for me.”

There is also an undercurrent of homoerotic “unconscious attraction” fuelling Javert’s pursuit of Valjean – according to Davies. And if all of that is not enough for viewers to put the strains of I Dreamed a Dream and One Day More out of their heads, the screenwriter offers a grudging solution. He says, through gritted teeth: “Well, I think they can hum the tunes in their head or out loud if they find that helps.”



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s